B2 · Upper-Intermediate · Debating Ethics · 526 words · ~3 min read

🧭 The Ethics of the Thing

Language focus: Expressing opinions & hedging · debating ethics

Act 2 · The Digital Nomad’s Trail

Jonas lived in a sprawling, plant-filled apartment that doubled as a workshop, every surface buried beneath cables, circuit boards and half-drunk cups of coffee. He waved Elif towards a battered sofa and came straight to the point. “Before I tell you anything,” he said, “I want to know exactly where you stand.”

What followed was less an interrogation than a genuine debate. Jonas argued that the whole industry had lost its moral compass; that data, once shared freely for the common good, had quietly been turned into a weapon. “I would go so far as to say,” he ventured, “that most so-called innovation these days is simply sophisticated theft with better lawyers.”

Elif pushed back, though carefully. “I take your point,” she said, “and yet I am inclined to think it is not quite so black and white. Firms have to protect their work, or no one would invest in research in the first place. The real question, surely, is not whether we protect ideas, but how — and at whose expense.”

They went back and forth like this for the better part of an hour, testing one another’s reasoning. Elif found that hedging her stronger opinions — “it could be argued”, “to some extent”, “I’d be inclined to say” — kept the discussion from hardening into a quarrel. Jonas, for all his bluster, clearly relished being taken seriously for once.

At last, satisfied, he opened his laptop. “Helian doesn’t invent anything,” he said flatly. “It harvests. It plants people inside promising startups — sometimes as employees, sometimes as consultants — who quietly siphon off the research. Then Helian patents it first and lets its lawyers handle the rest.” Elif felt the events of the past month click neatly into place.

“Victor Crane,” she said softly. Jonas looked up sharply. “You know about Victor? Then you already know more than you have been letting on.” He explained that Victor had been one of Helian’s most effective plants — until, by his account, the man had developed a conscience, threatened to expose the whole scheme, and been ruthlessly cut loose.

“So Victor isn’t the villain after all,” Elif murmured. “He’s a warning.” Jonas nodded grimly. “Whoever truly runs Helian does not make idle threats. If you decide to go after them, you had better make your evidence watertight, because they will come after everything you own — your company, your reputation, the lot.”

Elif weighed his words in silence. Part of her wanted to walk away, to repair Verda quietly and simply let Helian rot from the inside out. But she had never once been able to look the other way, and she suspected she never truly would. “Then help me,” she said. “Help me build a case that even their lawyers cannot bury.” Jonas studied her for a long moment, and then, slowly, deliberately, he began to talk. What he laid out over the next hour was more methodical, and a great deal more chilling, than anything she had dared to imagine — and by the end of it, Elif knew with cold certainty that there could be no quiet way out of this any more.

Key vocabulary (6 words)

interrogationnoun
A long, intense session of questioning.
reasoningnoun
The process of thinking about something in a logical way.
blusternoun
Loud, aggressive talk that has little real force behind it.
watertightadjective
So carefully prepared that it cannot be disproved or attacked.
schemenoun
A secret or clever plan, often dishonest.
ruthlesslyadverb
In a way that shows no pity or mercy.

Phrasal verbs in this chapter

  • push back — To push back means to express disagreement or resistance.
  • go after — To go after someone means to pursue or try to defeat them.
  • cut loose — To cut someone loose means to get rid of them, often suddenly.

Comprehension quiz

  1. What does Jonas want to know first?

    • Where Elif stands ethically
    • Her salary
    • Her address
    Show answer

    Where Elif stands ethically

  2. What is Jonas’s view of the industry?

    • It has lost its moral compass
    • It is perfect
    • It is too small
    Show answer

    It has lost its moral compass

  3. “Black and white” means seeing things as…

    • simple, with no middle ground
    • colourful
    • printed
    Show answer

    simple, with no middle ground

  4. Why does Elif hedge her opinions?

    • To keep the debate from becoming a quarrel
    • Because she is unsure of English
    • To waste time
    Show answer

    To keep the debate from becoming a quarrel

  5. What does Helian actually do?

    • Harvest others’ research and patent it first
    • Invent everything
    • Sell coffee
    Show answer

    Harvest others’ research and patent it first

  6. What happened to Victor Crane?

    • He developed a conscience and was cut loose
    • He was promoted
    • He won an award
    Show answer

    He developed a conscience and was cut loose

  7. “Cut loose” means to…

    • get rid of suddenly
    • tie up
    • reward
    Show answer

    get rid of suddenly

  8. “Watertight” evidence is…

    • impossible to disprove
    • very wet
    • easily attacked
    Show answer

    impossible to disprove

  9. “Look the other way” means to…

    • ignore wrongdoing on purpose
    • turn your head
    • read a map
    Show answer

    ignore wrongdoing on purpose

  10. What does Elif ask Jonas to do?

    • Help build an unbreakable case
    • Lend her money
    • Drive her home
    Show answer

    Help build an unbreakable case

All 20 B2 chapters

More graded reading & practice